"Totally off colour, 2/10" – Five players who flopped in the second round of the Autumn Nations Series

11/10/2024 02:33 PM

“Totally off colour” – that’s how some of the standout players in the second round of the Autumn Nations Series can be described.

RUCK's Autumn Nations Series coverage is proudly powered by the My Name'5 Doddie Foundation, dedicated to creating a world free of MND. Join the the fight against MND here.

While the competition has seen plenty of thrilling performances, a few high-profile names failed to deliver when their teams needed them most.

From misfires in key moments to lacklustre displays, these five players certainly didn't leave their mark in the way fans were hoping. Let's take a closer look at who fell short this time around.

#1. Henry Slade (England)

Slade, as the backline's defensive captain, took heavy criticism for Australia’s success in navigating the blitz defense. While Rugby Pass mentioned the defensive responsibilities shifting to Joe El-Abd, Slade was expected to be the top defensive presence and fell short.

Telegraph 4/10: “As the defensive captain of the backline needs to bear responsibility for how easily Australia navigated the blitz.”

Rugby Pass 6/10: “Struggled in a defensive set-up that is now the remit of Joe El-Abd. Needed to be his team's best defending back but was unable to provide that reliability.”

Mail Online 5/10: “He is the man in charge of England’s blitz defence, but it was cut to ribbons far too often by some razor-sharp Australian attack.”

Planet Rugby 3/10: “That defence was an absolute shambles and Slade made so many bad decisions. Better with ball in hand

#2. Bundee Aki (Ireland)

Aki received mixed reviews for his performance. Rugby Pass gave him 3/10, citing errors like a misjudged pass and spilled ball, while he struggled in attack. Planet Rugby rated him 5/10, noting uncharacteristic mistakes but praising his toughness in carrying the ball, despite not being at his best.

Rugby Pass 3/10: "A totally off-colour performance from Aki. Opened his account with a poorly timed pass which went to the deck before inexplicably spilling a ball a few minutes later. One good run aside, the All Blacks had his number in attack, where he struggled to make a meaningful impact."

Planet Rugby 5/10: "A few uncharacteristic errors like dropping the ball cold as he looked up at the defence rather than keeping his eye on it. Still, he was tough to bring to the ground when he carried to the line but not at his box office best."

#3. Scott Cummings (Scotland)

The Glasgow lock's game unraveled after an early yellow card for a croc roll, later upgraded to red. Planet Rugby rated him 2/10, Rugby Pass 4/10, and The Scotsman 5/10, all highlighting his initial impact but emphasizing the harsh call that disrupted Scotland's momentum.

Planet Rugby 2/10: “Sent to the sin-bin for a croc roll, which was later upgraded to a red card.”

Rugby Pass: 4/10: “The Glasgow lock stole an early Springboks lineout to make a nuisance of himself but received a harsh yellow card in the 11th minute for what was deemed a croc-roll, just as Scotland had built up a head of steam, leading to a penalty being overturned. Cummings looked suitably bemused as he headed to the touchline, even moreso when his offence was upgraded to a 20-minute red card, to widespread disbelief.”

The Scotsman 5/10: “Started the game well with a lineout steal – but it went south thereafter, sin-binned for a croc-roll in the breakdown that was upgraded to a 20-minute red card on 12 minutes. Scotland camp thought the award was harsh.”

#4. Tommy Reffell (Wales)

Reffell’s performance was marked by a disappointing yellow card in the 13th minute for a dangerous tackle, which Fiji felt should have been upgraded to red. Despite a strong start, the yellow card disrupted his game, and he gave away a couple of penalties. He was substituted early in the second half for Jac Morgan.

Rugby Pass 4/10: “Not his best day at the office, despite a bright start. Reffell was sent to the sin bin for a dangerous tackle in the 13th and he did not have the impact he would have hoped for once back on the pitch. Fiji certainly felt that his yellow card should have been upgraded to red and he gave away a couple of penalties before being replaced by Jac Morgan early in the second half.”

RUCK 5/10: “A clumsy yellow card costing Wales a try in the first half and cutting his playing minutes short. Was his usual formidable self at the ruck but the yellow card hampered any impact he could have on the game.”

#5. George Furbank (England)

Furbank’s performance lacked impact, with critics noting his quiet presence on the field. He didn't make the anticipated contributions in attack and failed to shut down Australia's two first-half tries in the same corner. Planet Rugby highlighted his overplaying, which led to errors and turnovers. He was replaced by George Ford, with Marcus Smith moving to full-back, after 18 minutes.

Mail Online 4.5/10: “Quiet. Didn’t necessarily do much wrong, but didn’t stand out either. Replaced by George Ford with Marcus Smith moving to full-back.”

Rugby Pass 4.5/10: “Didn't feature in attack as was hoped and it was disappointing that he didn't better shut the door defensively for Australia's two first half tries scored in the same corner. Sacrificed with 18 minutes remaining, with Smith switching to full-back.”

Planet Rugby 4/10: ” Was rightly heralded in July but Furbank was very poor on Sat

The post “Totally off colour, 2/10" – Five players who flopped in the second round of the Autumn Nations Series appeared first on Ruck.