Six Nations admit crucial error that cost England Six Nations title
Yesterday at 03:36 AM
England's Six Nations title hopes were dashed on Saturday after France defeated Scotland 35-16 in the final match of the tournament.
However, controversy erupted after tournament officials admitted a crucial refereeing mistake that could have altered the course of the competition.
Faces Disciplinary Hearing
French hooker Peato Mauvaka has been cited for foul play following an off-the-ball incident involving Scotland's Ben White. The clash, which occurred midway through the first half, saw Mauvaka launch himself headfirst into the grounded scrum-half. Despite the severity of the incident, the Frenchman was only shown a yellow card, with the decision reviewed by the bunker but left unchanged.
On Tuesday, it was confirmed that Mauvaka will face an independent disciplinary hearing on Thursday after being accused of striking an opponent with "any part of the arm, shoulder, head or knee." This has led to further debate over whether the initial decision should have resulted in a straight red card.
Townsend Left Baffled by Decision
Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend was left stunned by the decision not to send Mauvaka off during the crucial encounter in Paris. Speaking after the game, Townsend was adamant that the challenge merited more than a yellow.
"It clearly was a non-tackle incident, it was after the whistle. So, if there was head contact and that was intentional, it shouldn't be anything to do with the force that was involved," Townsend said.
"I feel sorry for Ben White here, because he did nothing. He was first of all pushed to the ground, and a push is nothing in rugby, and then he got collided in the head, so I don't know how it wasn't raised to a red card."
A Game-Changing Moment
Had Mauvaka been shown a red card, France would have been reduced to 14 men for the majority of the match. With Scotland trailing just 10-0 at the time and later cutting the deficit to 16-13 before half-time, the outcome could have been vastly different. A Scottish victory would have handed the Six Nations title to England.
Andy Goode: "That Should Have Been a Red"
Former England fly-half Andy Goode was equally surprised by the decision. Taking to X, formerly known as Twitter, Goode expressed his disbelief.
"That should be a red for Mauvaka," Goode wrote.
He later added: "So a flying head into the face of a player lying prone on the floor is just a yellow card?! Mauvaka should have seen a full red card for that, not even a 20-minute one. The bunker system has had a shocker."
France Seize Control Despite Controversy
Mauvaka returned to the field with France leading 13-10, and despite the contentious decision, the hosts went on to dominate the second half, securing a comfortable 35-16 victory and clinching the Six Nations title.
EDITORS PICKS:
- Competition: A chance to roar the Lions on down under in Sydney and Melbourne!
- Team of the Tournament: 2025 Guinness Men's Six Nations
- Four nominees announced for Six Nations Player of the Tournament
- "Be Yourself" – Henry Pollock reveals what Ellis Genge said to him upon his England debut
- "It's devastating"- Wales coach Matt Sherratt reacts to record 68-14 defeat to England
- England's 2025 Six Nations Players Ranked From Best to Worst
Four uncapped England players Steve Borthwick should call up this summer
As Steve Borthwick looks to build depth in England's squad ahead of the next World Cup cycle, a summer series presents the perfect opportunity to blood fresh talent.
With several experienced names likely heading on the Lions tour, these four uncapped players deserve a shot to make their mark in the white jersey.
FOUR UNCAPPED PLAYERS:
Gabriel Ibitoye – Harlequins (Wing)
A lethal finisher with footwork to rival the best, Gabriel Ibitoye has been electric since returning to Harlequins after stints in France and Israel. The 26-year-old brings a unique blend of pace, power, and unpredictability that England's backline has sorely missed.
Ibitoye's ability to create something out of nothing makes him a nightmare for defenders, and his defensive work has also improved significantly. If Borthwick wants a dynamic threat out wide, Ibitoye is ready to answer the call.
Max Ojomoh – Bath (Centre)
A classy operator in the midfield, Max Ojomoh has been knocking on the England door for a while. With smooth distribution, intelligent running lines, and a solid defensive presence, the Bath centre offers a well-rounded skillset.
Ojomoh's ability to play at inside centre or shift to 13 gives Borthwick tactical flexibility, and his understanding of space makes him a creative link between the forwards and backs. With Ollie Lawrence a regular now, pairing him with Ojomoh could add another dimension to England's attack.
CONTINUES ON PAGE TWO
The post Six Nations admit crucial error that cost England Six Nations title appeared first on Ruck.
