Five Most Overrated Players in Six Nations History
Today at 05:55 AM
In the world of rugby debates, few topics ignite passions quite like the dreaded “overrated” label. It's a conversation that stretches beyond a player's on-field brilliance, dragging fan hype and media bias into the mix.
Find your local Greene King and settle in for the 2025 Six Nations!
When it comes to Six Nations stars, the divide can be striking. Some greats are deemed “overrated” simply because their reputation outpaces their current performances, while lesser-known players bask in the “underrated” spotlight. But is it really their fault? Blame social media, relentless punditry, or a bit of both.
Still, we're diving headfirst into this controversy because, let's face it, what's rugby without a bit of spice? And thanks to the voters over at TheTopTens.com, we've got a lineup of players who've sparked some serious debate.
Join the RUCK's WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
The Top Five Overrated Rugby Players
#5. George North (Wales)
Born in 1992, George North burst onto the scene as a teenage sensation, scoring two tries on his international debut against South Africa in 2010. Known for his blistering pace and physicality, the versatile wing and centre became one of Wales’ most recognisable players during their Six Nations triumphs in 2012 and 2013. However, injuries and inconsistent form have seen his performances decline in recent years, leading to criticism of his ongoing hype.
“He had a few good years between 2011-2013 and then he has died down. Hasn’t looked good as the commentary teams make him out to be.”
"George bloody North!"
#4. Chris Ashton (England)
Chris Ashton, born in 1987, began his career in rugby league before switching codes and becoming one of England's most prolific try-scorers in union. Famous for his signature “Ash Splash” try celebration, Ashton thrived at clubs like Northampton Saints and Saracens. He earned 44 caps for England, scoring 20 tries, but his career has often been marred by criticism of his defensive frailties and reliance on finishing the work of others.
“Lazy player with a terrible workrate, decent positioning at times that sees him finish off the good work of other players and get all the undeserved credit. Poor tackler too.”
"That man lived off his 'solo' try against Australia and managed to get in the England team every time. He couldn't tackle a crossword!"
#3. Alun Wyn Jones (Wales)
Born in 1985, Alun Wyn Jones is a Welsh rugby icon and the most capped international player of all time, with 170 caps for Wales and 12 for the British & Irish Lions. Known for his leadership, grit, and longevity, Jones has been instrumental in numerous Six Nations championships and Lions tours. However, some critics argue that his late-career performances haven't matched the hype surrounding his legendary status.
“At this point he only gets chosen because Wales Online will go nuclear and blow up Cardiff if he doesn’t.”
“I really, really don't understand why he is rated so highly.”
One fan clapped back, saying: “Maybe he's got 12 Lions caps in a row, numerous Six Nations titles, and two World Player of the Year nominations because he's one of the greatest locks of all time… maybe.”
#2. Sergio Parisse (Italy)
Sergio Parisse, born in Argentina in 1983, is widely regarded as one of Italy's greatest-ever players. The dynamic No. 8 earned 142 caps for the Azzurri over two decades, showcasing incredible skills, leadership, and flair. However, many critics believe his reputation was inflated due to being a standout performer in an otherwise struggling Italy team, with claims he prioritised flashy moments over substance.
“Sure, he had fantastic skills, but he was a show pony and not a workhorse.”
“Never has a cliché fit a player more than 'overrated show pony' for Sergio Parisse."
#1. Sébastien Chabal (France)
Born in 1977, Sébastien Chabal is one of rugby's most recognisable figures, thanks to his imposing frame and iconic beard. Nicknamed “The Caveman,” Chabal earned 62 caps for France, playing across the back row and second row. While he became a global cult hero for his bone-crunching tackles and fearsome persona, critics argue his overall impact on matches didn't justify the hype surrounding him.
“His appearance was half his reputation. Whenever he was given the appropriate attention, he folded.”
“Good 6, terrible 8, even worse lock.”
So, there you have it. Whether you agree or not, these players have sparked endless debates among rugby fans. One thing's for sure—being called “overrated” doesn't take away from their place in rugby's history books.
EDITORS PICKS:
- Ilona Maher is one of rugby's richest stars with huge net worth
- Stuart Lancaster has signed another England star for Racing 92
- Ranked: The 50 Greatest British & Irish Lions Players of All Time – Who's No.1?
- Fans Are Only Just Realising Where They Recognise Eben Etzebeth's Wife From
- Michael Cheika to depart Leicester with likely replacement revealed
Quiz: Can you all of the Guinness Six Nations winning captains?
Securing victory in the Guinness Six Nations is undoubtedly special, but achieving this triumph as a captain is a feat that remains a distant dream for many.
In the storied history of Rugby’s Greatest Championship, exceptional leaders have emerged—warriors of various forms, be they agile half-backs, towering second rows, or fearless flankers.
Our latest quiz invites you to identify those who have captained their nations to Guinness Six Nations glory. It’s worth noting that in certain instances, there may be multiple captains from the same year due to factors such as injuries and rotation.
Surnames only will be accepted.
The post Five Most Overrated Players in Six Nations History appeared first on Ruck.
